Better Evaluation

Hey everyone,

I just wanted to share this.

I think that the evaluation of potential new members could be better then it is right now.
I know that we have different sections where the tester will judge the potential new member on things like Attitude and Originality. But just look at the test results!

When I see a test result, I will see things like this:

section 1: X/10 points
section 2: X/15 points
section 3: X/10 points
etc.

I can see that it has been that way for a long time on here but I don't think that the way of showing how the tester judged the potential new member is really good.

I think that the tester should explain a little about why he gave that certain guy that certain amount of point.

Originality: 2/10
Attitude: 6/10

Yeah cool and all, but it doesn't say very much..

I'm just saying, if I would be a tester, I would explain why I gave a certain amount of point to that potential new member.


I think this would also be a better way of judging potential new members because of the fact that in this case, not only the tester can judge the potential new member, but all the others can give theire opinion on him too.


Another thing, I know that it has been mentioned, but all the testers should have the exact same deck(s) for testing potential new members. This should be more fair for everyone that wants to join the academy.
And I think that we should all vote on the decks for the testers to use.

And yet another thing.
I've looked at several test results.. Obviously, the points a certain player obtains will decide what will be that player's dorm.
Now this is my conclusion:

Max points: 85

Elite green: 85!!
Shooting Star blue: 80+
Scar-Red red: 70+
70- is Black...

In my opinion, this should be changed so people can get in higher dorms a little easier.
Doesn't have to be lowered alot.. But this is just too high.
Btw. If I am incorrect about the red part then tell me. It is just what I have seen.

Plz tell me what you all think about this....

Thank you for your time.

-Gianus




Note: I did not want to offend anyone. I am sorry if it seems that way but my English is not perfect. I hope you all can understand that.

i think the admins are actually already considering the part about identical decks, so your point there is good

however, the point of getting higher dorms is for it to be challenging. if it was easier to get into higher dorms, then everyone would crowd blue.

i completely agree with the part about testers.
i'll make sure to do that in the future.

it wasn't offensive at all, and your english is fine (:

good ideas!

getting in high groups takes more points...and skill...IT SHOULD NOT BE EASIER.

Drew Money wrote:

getting in high groups takes more points...and skill...IT SHOULD NOT BE EASIER.

But these standars are just ridicyulous!

I think that at least the red dorm should be easier to get in...